Living in the Netherlands. Learning about the world of filmmaking, and eager to join. Award winning amateur director, and enthousiast writer.
Many people criticize the Tarkin effect, saying the words "Uncanny Valley" a lot, but I could not tell. If I didn't know Cushing has been dead for decades, I would have been fooled.
So cool they answered my question! And in the same week John August read my email on Scriptnotes!
That is a very narrow-minded approach to analyze it. I mean, sure, if you didn't like it, that's your opinion. I might not agree, but what are ya gonna do?
However, if you just look at it objectively, which you should be doing since you're on NFS, you can appreciate the amazing visual effects work done on it. Sure, the story made no sense, but from a VFX standpoint, it is absolutely amazing. And that's not an opinion, but a fact.
Because Stormtroopers aren't all clones of Jango... Most of the clones died in the Death Star's destruction and were replaced by volunteers and guns for hire.
Or 16th, depending where you live!