The Mare: DID HE JUST CHOP OFF HIS DICK?????? FINGER???? IM CONFUSED. I thought this one was definitely unsettling, largely thanks to the actor portraying the girl, the fantastic concept of the sign-language scene, and the black-and-white quality, I think, but it was scary, exactly.
The Girl in the Hallway: that's so sad... RIP Xiana Fairchild. And the title along with presenting the story as the reason that the Little Red Riding Hood fairy tale gives him nightmares, was really creative. But I wasn't scared by that either.