December 2, 2015

How Christopher Nolan's Use of Hands in His Films Helps You Think Like a Detective

If you could use only one word to describe Christopher Nolan's work it'd probably be "cerebral".

The lion's share of his films, like FollowingMemento, and even a big budget franchise iteration like The Dark Knight, all have Nolan's cinematic signatures -- non-linear stories, flashbacks, and visual symmetry. But perhaps one of Nolan's more interesting trademarks is the way he first introduces his protagonists in the first scene of his films -- by showing a close-up of their hands.

In fact, Nolan pays a lot of attention to hands and gesticulation -- something Jorge Luengo Ruiz explores in this interesting supercut:

If the first thing you thought of when watching this video was, "Whoa, this reminds me of Robert Bresson," then you are one hell of a film scholar and I'd like to be your friend. It's true, though. Bresson paid close attention to hands, which is something we delved into about a year back with kogonada's supercut "Hands of Bresson" (which inspired Ruiz's "Hands of Nolan"), and if we've learned anything from that study, it's that a lot can be said with a simple gesture.

Nolan uses close-ups of hands to do many different things: reveal a key element of the plot or character, communicate the emotional state of a character, or simply show an action. Think of how Leonard meticulously captures Polaroids or frantically writes notes in Memento, or how Cobb carries around and spins the top in Inception. In many ways, Nolan's characters think with their hands.

In other words, we don't often see his characters' eyes squinting, their lips pursing, their brows furrowing as they contemplate -- much like we would in films by other filmmakers. Instead, Nolan imbues these objects with the thoughts and ideas of his characters. So, the Polaroids, notes, and tops are not just simple props or visual metaphors -- they also act as an extension of the characters' mind. If we think of the objects within the diegesis as "the mind", then clearly the hands are "the body" -- "thought" and "action". 

This could be the reason why Nolan's films feel so cerebral. Many times other films would cut to a vast landscape or even a close-up of a face -- why does Nolan cut to hands? Well, if you think about it -- landscapes, buildings, etc. give you spacial information, faces/eyes give you an emotional response; what do hands do? Strangely, they make you think. "What are they doing with that top? Why are they frantically writing that note? What's on that shell casing that makes it so important?" Focusing on hands turns us into detectives, and Nolan is one of the greatest mystery makers of our time.      

Your Comment

5 Comments

I love it, it is very curious how Nolan Pays attention to the hands. I will observe more his films.

December 3, 2015 at 1:08AM, Edited December 3, 1:08AM

0
Reply
avatar
Victor Hugo Muñoz Herrera
Director, Writer, Producer, and VFX Artist
166

I like that this montage also shows a progression in technical finesse and aesthetic, all while he maintains his style.

December 3, 2015 at 2:02AM

0
Reply
avatar
Samu Amunét
Director
290

Although I dislike his later works I lot, I can't deny that Nolan's visuals are beautifully unique!

December 5, 2015 at 6:47AM

0
Reply
avatar
Benjamin Skorov
Somehow all of it, Hobbyist, Essayist
340

Love the article, very keen observation. We must make a subconscious connection between hands and thought when we write. Another movie with a powerful use of hands is Henri-Georges Clouzot's "The Wages of Fear". The hand is alone, but has more power than a person would have in that place.

December 8, 2015 at 10:58AM

3
Reply
avatar
David Barrington
Videographer
220

All this time.....he was making US into Batman...........the mind explodes.

December 8, 2015 at 6:41PM, Edited December 8, 6:41PM

0
Reply
Jeremy Abbott
Video Producer/Independent Filmmaker
321