September 24, 2016

The Socially Anxious Framing of 'Mr. Robot' and How It's Used to Tell Stories

This is how framing can change everything about your story.

There are lots of different ways to convey emotions on screen, from explicitly verbalizing it with dialog to tapping into the psychological effects of color. But framing shots in specific ways can also be extremely effective at communicating a character's mental and emotional state. Video essayist James Hayes of Film in the Making talks a bit about how the creators of the Emmy award-winning TV series Mr. Robot used framing, namely quadrant framing, to communicate the social anxiety and distrust experienced by its protagonist, a vigilante hacker named Elliot.

There are many different established theories about composition that look to explain how a subject's positioning within a frame affects the audience's interpretation of that scene. The popular concept of the "Rule of Thirds" states that the frame is divided by imaginary horizontal and vertical guide lines that create a multi-quadrant grid, the intersections of which serve as focal points for important features of the image (faces, objects, etc.)

There are a lot of ways to play around with this concept, like, yes, placing important stuff at an intersection, but you can also communicate different things by placing your subject within a certain quadrant. For example, placing Elliot in the bottom left quadrant gives the impression that he is isolated, even untrusting of the world around him. The reason for this stems from the relationship between "negative space" and "positive space." (Negative space is the space that surrounds a subject, while positive space is the subject itself.) If a subject, which is traditionally the focal point of a composition, only takes up a small fraction of the frame, the negative space becomes much more noticeable and even overpowering, which can result in eliciting emotions like loneliness, isolation, distrust, suspicion, and powerlessness.

If you want to learn more about the psychological and emotional effects of framing and composition, you should check out our other articles on the subject, like how director Nicolas Winding Refn uses some interesting framing acrobatics to convey subtle emotional messages.      

Your Comment

5 Comments

Love me some Mr. Robot! Though I've seen this technique used prior in stuff like "Luther" with Idris Elba, I feel like Tod Campbell was seriously inspired by stuff like that.

September 25, 2016 at 1:20AM

0
Reply

Indeed.
In Luther you can see the same feeling of isolation.
Love it!

September 26, 2016 at 10:00AM

1
Reply
avatar
WalterBrokx
Director, DOP, Writer, Editor, Producer
8864

I know many people that been disturbed by this technique include myself.
i would like to read more about this.

September 25, 2016 at 6:40AM

0
Reply
avatar
Multiflave
Director , Editor , Audio Engineer
183

I have loved the framing for this show. There's one scene in season 2 where E Corp CEO Phillip Price is framed up tiny in the left bottom corner. He's dejected but then has a long monologue about how he has to be the most powerful man in the room, everywhere he goes. The camera slow dollies in toward him and ends with Phillip Price filling the entire frame.

September 25, 2016 at 7:25AM, Edited September 25, 7:26AM

3
Reply

I don't know, I felt it often become too gimmickous and therefore distracting for the story (until it became so hole-ridden it didn't matter anymore). Good start though, but in the end just another exploitation of the 99%.

On a side note, did anyone tell you guys that your huge youtube embed doesn't fit FF window on a 1080p screen? Why would you do that?

September 30, 2016 at 1:37PM

0
Reply
avatar
zetty
Filmmaker
674

A great explanation of the framing: https://youtu.be/Xc5bc33Ybys

October 7, 2016 at 1:44AM

1
Reply