The Kuleshov effect is the essential concept of editing, if not all of filmmaking. Do you know how to use it?
We all know that film is a visual medium. But we often forget that it's not that old. We've only had Hollywood movies for about 100 years. And while storytelling is as old as time, the way we design and edit movies and television to tell those stories is relatively new. Techniques are developed all the time.
And most of them are based on the Kuleshov effect.
Today, we're doing to dig into the effect and check out a video made by Senior Post.
Let's cut right to it.
Table of Contents
Who is Kuleshov?
Lev Kuleshov was a Russian filmmaker and considered to be one of the first film theorists. In 1910, he posed this question to filmmakers:
"What made cinema a distinct art, separate from photography, literature or theatre?"
While this seems simple to answer now, he wanted to create a real distinction between the artistic mediums. So he answered that art was defined but what it was made of and how those materials were organized.
Yes, it does sound like he took all the fun out of filmmaking, but stick with me.
The Kuleshov Effect Definition
It is a cognitive event in which viewers derive more meaning from the interaction of two sequential shots than from a single shot in isolation.
How Did Kuleshov Prove His Effect?
In 1921, Kuleshov set up a series of cinematic demonstrations that cut back and forth between a man and three different things to see what emotions could be created with the contrast.
The soup showed hunger.
The dead kid showed sadness.
The woman showed lust.
This theory defined film and film editing. It proved that a film is just the juxtaposition of two shots, sewn together to create emotions. These shots can manipulate space and time. And manipulate the audience's reaction to each of them.
With this deduction in place, all of the film world moved forward as an artistic medium. Now modern filmmakers knew they could elicit anything they wanted from the watching audience just by editing new shots. And from those editing techniques grew a whole slew of different creative camera angles that could complement the editing and be used to tell stories.
Filmmakers across the world were excited by the Kuleshov effect. And it kept influencing people even as the 1920s passed.
Even Hitchcock got in on it.
Video is no longer available: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNVf1N34-io
The Kuleshov Effect Examples
While the effect seems like a no brainer in today's film world, I wanted to go over three examples to help show how the definition of the Kuleshov effect can inspire your editing, direction, and even screenwriting.
First up, let's look at the cuts in the "What's in the box" scene in Seven.
This scene is built around cutting back and forth from the box to each person's reactions. What's fun here is that Fincher uses three completely separate emotions to all refer to the box. There's Brad Pitt's horror. Morgan Freeman's fear. And the killer's elation.
These distinct emotions all work when you cut back and forth to the box because the audience needs to know all three points of view for the scene to progress. Fincher is a master of audience control here. We are made to feel our own reaction to this scene. We are steeped in shock and awe as we realize the villain has won.
What about using the effect to trick the audience?
In Jonathan Demme's The Silence Of The Lambs, we use the Kuleshov effect and cross-cutting to set us up for am emotional reveal. By going back and forth from Buffalo Bill to the FBI, we have tensions rise.
The best part about this is how the rug gets pulled out from under us. As an audience, we had something like 70 years of editing to lull us into thinking the killer had been found. But the payoff of this scene, they the FBI and reinforcements are miles away from Clarice Starling, who is now in mortal peril, is epic.
What about a movie that uses the Kuleshov effect over and over as a major plot point?
I'm talking about Inside Out.
Inside Out Is a movie built on what goes on inside out head, and how that makes us feel. So in a lot of parts of this movie, we use what the human character is seeing to then influence how the characters inside her head feel. This is a clever take on editing because we handle multiple perspectives an emotions, just like in Seven, but this time it carries for the whole movie. Everyone is constantly reacting to the way the girl feels and in different ways.
This is not only a genius use of the Kuleshov effect on the plot, but also an incredibly deep read on audience perspective and complex characterization.
Leave it to Pixar to deliver another storytelling homerun.
So what did we learn from these examples?
Summing Up The Kuleshov Effect
The Kuleshov effect may have influenced every filmmaker that came after it, but there are new ways to employ it in your editing, direction, and writing.
The biggest takeaway from these Kuleshov effect examples and definition is that you are always in control of the audience. The best filmmakers exploit that control, subvert that control, and respect that control.
So the next time you sit down at the editing bay, ask how you want the audience to feel.
Then edit for that.
I can't wait to watch what your dream up!
Check-Out: Pro Video, Pro Audio, Lighting – Great Deals on Gear you made need !!
With any & every B&H purchase You will automatically be entered into the Monthly Gift Card Raffle.
January 31, 2019 at 4:26AM
November 26, 2019 at 4:12AM, Edited November 26, 4:12AM
Great Analysis, THANK YOU.
May 21, 2021 at 10:42AM
This idea has been gospel for years. It makes sense, doesn't it?
However some years back someone set up an experiment to see if it actually worked. And it didn't.
Here's an interesting read https://www.jstor.org/stable/1225144
December 30, 2021 at 5:25PM