The footage I've seen of Ang Lee's Life of Pi (released today) so far looks pretty fantastic. I know it's adapted from a novel, I know there's a man and a tiger on a boat, but other than that I really know nothing about this movie -- just that it looks intriguing from a pure imagery standpoint. That, and the next logical step from there, which is that it is probably going to be breathtaking in stereo. How does one create a soundtrack suitable for the visual side of this experience? Thanks once again to Michael Coleman's Soundworks Collection, we now have an inkling of exactly that -- and of how the sound design team crafted it for Dolby Atmos -- beginning with almost no usable production tracks.
Check out the trailer first, if you haven't seen it yet:
Video is no longer available: www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_profilepage&v=mX2HBsHbNZM
You read that right. You might be thinking that for any kind of fantasy or science fiction film, perhaps it's actually easier, in a sense, to start from scratch. But it's still mighty impressive. As for filling it all in, see below:
Any time the very nature (literally) of the shooting environment compromises the integrity or flexibility of the production track (as was the case in Lord of the Rings, see page 2) -- and this can quickly become true, and understandably so, when shooting on the water -- the sound design team must basically build from the ground up. The production audio recordings become reference tracks at best, and there's far more work to be done than may usually (or hopefully) be the case. Especially with a fantasy-adventure sort of film like Life of Pi, the treatment of this task is key. The soundtrack must fit the film without being so otherworldly as to cause a disconnect, AKA invoking the dreaded suspension-of-suspension-of-disbelief.
The benefit of having a clean slate for sound is control. I can only imagine that the single channel production track would need quite a bit of sprucing-up for it to work in Dolby Atmos anyway, and the re-recording allowed the sound team to widen their options. For instance (visible 01:47), in some cases they could optimize the number of channels (mics) and relative directionality (placement of mics) necessary to give themselves a lot more room to play around. Another example (visible just prior to the latter) are the proximities to the water and hull at which certain recordings could be made -- another mic perspective ability the production track would simply be unable to provide. In the hectic atmosphere of shooting on location (especially in an environment as unpredictable as the ocean), this fine-tuned type of sound recording would be basically impossible in tandem with a production schedule.
Of course, this sort of work is what a sound design team would be doing regardless, but I can imagine that recording, finding, and blending enough recordings to seamlessly match the reference track and therefore the footage (think things like individual waves and splashes) could really become painstaking. The great value of the Soundworks Collection is the appreciation it hopefully instills in us for all that hard work and artistry -- I mean, I understand what's going on, I love every one of these videos, and I can still hardly believe that people recorded (and sifted through to pick the best of) every single one of the things you're hearing in that Atmos-equipped theater.
Have any of you guys ever had to build (or should I say 'rebuild') the entirety of the soundtrack to any scenes, never mind complete films you've made? What have you found to be the most difficult aspects of starting from scratch in such cases? Any sound designers out there who miss silent cinema?
Your Comment
4 Comments
The studio I work for, SDG Pictures, has actually just finished a project like that.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfV3jhG2BXE&feature=plcp
All of the sounds you hear in this video were recorded later and added in in post. The hardest part for me (I was the sound designer) was to syncronise longer sounds, such as the parts where the character is stirring his tea and pouring the water and milk. The trouble actually came from the fact that we had planned to do a silent film with just soundtrack, but as we were assembling the short, we realized that the story wouldn't hold itself without the sound effects to clairify some actions.
November 21, 2012 at 6:02AM, Edited September 4, 7:54AM
I'm doing something far small obviously, but basically the same thing myself.. We had a problem with in camera audio, and combined with no experienced audio personnel on set we didn't get much good sound. So I'm rebuilding the full 22 minutes of soundtrack for my short.
The folly is pretty straight forward but ADR is harder, and difficult to get the right perspective with and get the actors into the same head space as the character. The biggest issue I'm having now is music. There are some amazing audio tracks out there ready to go but, nothing that's dead on so I'm looking at outsourcing that. That would be a first time for me.
The reoccurring questions I've had throughout have been; when is the best time to do folly, when to do music when to do the grade because they all affect each other. Right now with a near final cut I think I need to grade before I sort the music out. When I started however the rough cut needed a lot of audio work even to make sense!
November 21, 2012 at 10:38AM, Edited September 4, 7:54AM
This is definitely going to be movie of the year, because it will be story of the year, it helps also that it is adapted from an intriguing novel. So far most critics agree that Director Lee did a good with combination of screeplay that many thought were impossible to do. A film like inception that will have many who have not read the book searching online for deeper info.
I also like the fact that the director used basically unknown actors and actresses in this movie, the movie is not only bold in that fashion, but that it also touches on religion, if only more directors/hollywood broke barriers like this. I dont know the budget for this movie but im sure that its on par with that of AVENGERS, cant think of the last big name budget that used unknown actors.
November 21, 2012 at 3:25PM, Edited September 4, 7:54AM
Wow goosebumps from a trailer, dont think I've ever experienced that before now.
November 22, 2012 at 12:23AM, Edited September 4, 7:54AM