Yesterday's Tragic Accident Shows Why We Should Ban Real Guns from Film Sets

The death of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on a film set is yet another reminder to ban any gun with a firing pin from a film set.

When news spread this morning of the tragic death of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on a film shoot in New Mexico after a prop gun was discharged on set, the industry was distraught. While details are scarce, it appears to be a weapon fired in a scene by the actor Alec Baldwin that somehow was able to kill the cinematographer.

This is absolutely horrible. No one should ever die, or come into any risk of injury, for a movie shoot. I can't stop thinking about the Hutchins family, and the work family we build up in years of shooting, and what a devastating loss this is for all of them of someone in the prime of life entering the prime of their career.

Now is the time to take action as a result of this horrible incident and ban real guns with firing pins from film sets.

I have owned guns, personally, and think there are arguments for and against doing so, personally, outside of a work environment.  But film sets aren't the site of armed resistance to tyranny or or grounds for hunting—they are workplaces. There is absolutely no need to have any weapon on a film set that is functional and designed for killing, outside perhaps the holster of well-trained security performing that task with dedicated focus. Whether you are using blanks or not, clearly accidents keep happening, and they are easily avoidable.

It is shocking that this happened for so many reasons, but it's particularly shocking because this isn't even the first time this has happened.

In 1984, Jon-Erik Hexum shot himself in the head while playing around between takes to lighten the mood. The blank in the gun killed him. In 1993 Brandon Lee died on set from a mistake with how the blanks were prepared. 

We work in the world of movie magic. Between sound design, CGI, and practical effects, it is very simple to create realistic gunfire. Even way back in 1993, there were many calls to ban guns from film sets; one of my first memories of reading about filmmaking was Peter David suggesting as much after the death of Brandon Lee. Use of prop non-guns, that make a bang and emit a little flash, but can't load a real bullet or have a firing pin, could be used. Real guns, blanks or no, shouldn't be allowed.

Many argue that blanks are safe, but blanks have already killed two actors, and while we don't yet know what happened in New Mexico, we do know a weapon that is designed for killing was brought to a set. Either the blanks were prepared incorrectly, or the gun was misloaded with live ammo, but either situation would've been avoided with a ban on real guns on set and an insistence on non-guns.

Beyond that, we need universal recognition that no one should ever be in harm's way in case there is an accident.

If there are weapons scenes being shot, we need to do what we do with all heavier stunts and car work. There should be a zone of safety where all camera equipment is operated remotely in the area where debris might fall.

In 2021 remote heads are too good, and too affordable, to do otherwise. The fact that the director and cinematographer were both hit, with the cinematographer fatally injured, makes it likely that the gun was fired either toward a camera or toward video village. In either situation, a proper zone of safety for accidents wasn't created. If a gun comes out, even a non-gun, get our crews further from set and remote operate any camera or lighting gear that needs to be closer to the scene.

It's astounding that 28 years after Brandon Lee, this is still legal. It has to be fixed, as quickly as possible. If laws can't do it, then our unions and guilds need to intervene.

Nothing with a real firing pin on a film set. A very short search finds rental houses renting "non-guns" which have no ability to fire anything but are rigged to create muzzle flashes. There is absolutely no reason to work with anything else.

This feels like an area that is ripe for SAG leadership. So far we have two actors who have died from this, and now a cinematographer. However, the actor who held the gun, Baldwin, will inevitably have emotional distress from the incident in which he likely carries no blame. We don't know full details yet, but it's likely the armorer's error, and initial word is that it was a non-union armorer, though that isn't confirmed.

Regardless, for decades Baldwin has been handed prop guns by armorers and put his faith in those professionals that they are safe. Now due to the error of an armorer he will have tremendous emotional fallout, and someone is dead, and the ramifications for their family can't be quantified. SAG should take leadership in banning all firing pins from set for the protection of their actors, working in collaboration with IATSE and the DGA.

SAG makes sense, since even on "smaller" films the actors are usually SAG. This film is a great example—SAG crew, Local 600 cinematographer, and non-union armorer. Mixing union cast and non-union crew is very common on lower-budget productions. SAG working together with Local 600 can make real change happen here so this can never happen again and no other crew member has to die this horrible way.

A law would be even better, but it's likely that any law with "gun" in it is going to be too controversial to pass pretty much anywhere, even something as sensible as "no guns in a workplace where they aren't needed." But where the law can't protect us, we can protect ourselves.

I know I'll never work with a real gun again, and I'll insist in pre-production on projects that we secure non-guns. I hope others take the same stance.     

You Might Also Like

Your Comment

9 Comments

apparently idiots in Hwood never learn. Of course you never bring real working guns on a set...yall a bunch of liberal idiots that know nothing about guns. its like leaving the kids around an open fire with no adult supervision.

October 22, 2021 at 3:23PM

0
Reply
StevieRay
171

I stopped reading after "blah blah blah liberals..."

October 23, 2021 at 12:05PM

1
Reply
avatar
David Patrick Raines
Actor/Writer/Director
231

Very unfortunate and sad that this happened. I will say that 3 gun related deaths in 37 years seems like they do a pretty good job considering how much guns are used in movies. How many people have been killed on set due to negligence? Such as being struck by a train on supposedly abandon tracks. I believe negligence typically stems from trying to save time and money. That is where I think attention should be given. I would not blame a gun anymore than I would blame a rope breaking that was not properly secured. We only hear when something goes wrong, but not how many times it goes right. Productions go to extravagant lengths for set safety and I hope that people also see that when a horrible incident like this occurs.

October 22, 2021 at 8:04PM

7
Reply

I don't know how it is in Hollywoo, but sometimes it's cheaper to use a real gun than a fake. If it was the other way around, how many would use a real gun? I think Sam has a good point. A gun on set obviously isn't the only danger.

October 24, 2021 at 4:06AM

0
Reply

Yeah, this seems like a no-brainer. It’s not like there aren’t plenty of viable alternatives to using actual firearms.

October 24, 2021 at 8:51AM

0
Reply
avatar
Bryan Howell
Screenwriter, corporate videographer, and indie filmmaker
646

I agree with the sentiment of this article, but not the recommendations. I would like all accidents to be avoided. There will always be accidents on sets. While we still don't know all the details, we do know it should have been avoided. Trying to blame the gun is always the wrong. I don't know but I believe that the gun was loaded with dummy rounds or spent rounds and somehow a live blank round was put in the gun which I think was a revolver. Which would be hard for Alec to clear, forcing him to trust what he was told. I don't want to speculate on any real details here if someone knows more please post. We should address what went wrong, not just say no more guns on set, because that is just not practical, less we end up with a complete CGI filmmaking.

October 24, 2021 at 7:37PM

0
Reply
Darren Orange
Director/Producer
305

It is time to ban cars. Only fake or toy are should be allowed on the roads. To many people are killed in the car accidents.
Or it is about rules and safety? Not the cars itself?

October 24, 2021 at 11:39PM

0
Reply
avatar
Regis.U
Filmmaker
242

I'm not sure that guns specifically are the problem or that banning them is the solution.

43 people have died on film sets since 1990 and only three of those deaths were gun related. To me, that's not a gun problem, it's a general safety problem. And it's not that these things *can't* be done safely, it's that when time or money is tight, they *aren't* done safely.

Whether it's a gunfight or a motorcycle chase, there's probably a way to do it safely, if you're willing to spend the time and money to let the professionals do their jobs. If not, you should not include those elements in your film, or just do them with CGI and hope nobody cares that it looks a little off.

October 25, 2021 at 1:26PM

0
Reply

In the recent past we have had deaths on set involving cars and Trains Are you not going to work with these real pieces of machinery as well. From Reports from set Baldwin was waving the weapon around responsibly and there was a major break down in basic firearm safety in general. I have worked on shoots where people were injured permanently from the improper use of a chapman dolly. The fact that an avoid gun hater who obviously had no real firearm safety or respect negligently discharged a weapon that had been mishandled by a prop crew that appears to have had no training as well. is the issue here and not the use of real guns.

October 26, 2021 at 1:39PM

0
Reply
Blaine Drayer
Videographer, Makeup, LD, TD, Engineer, Props
81